Reader Info
Advertising, subscriptions, staff, privacy policy, contact info, freelancers' guidelines, etc.




Chicagoland
A Reader staff blog. Photo by Lynn Haller. | RSS | Archive | Search


Michael Steele, former lieutenant governor of Maryland (he lost his race for Senate) got the crowd chanting DRILL BABY DRILL. That was AWESOME. To steal a neologism from Stephen Colbert, it was crasstastic! I would kill for a McCain t-shirt with that slogan. Both parties need to be more like Threadless.

Mitt Romney: words cannot express how much I'll miss him after November. He's camp for political junkies, this incredibly earnest, pretty, expensive figure who looks perfect on paper and at first glance, but who observation quickly reveals to be just busted. He's like the Legends of the Fall of politicians. "Tyrannosaurus appetite of government unions." See how it's just slightly off, like a chair with a leg that's just a bit too short? That's Mitt Romney. He has everything except talent.

I can't actually say anything bad about Mike Huckabee other than that I disagree with virtually all his actual political stances. He's the only good speaker in the Republican party--he sounds exactly like John Edwards, actually, but the difference between Edwards and Huckabee is the difference between good and great. His only competition right now in political oratory is Obama. He's also the only politician who sounds thoughtful about Christianity, especially off the cuff, as one would hope from someone with an M.Div.

Wow, who thought it was a good idea to bring up eloping? Paraphrasing: "They face the challenges that parents throughout America face": her daughter's pregnancy is a qualification. Well played!

I've been trying to figure out what the deal is with the pictures behind the podium is, and I finally figured it out: it's a screensaver!

Rudy using "community organizer" as a punchline was slick. "Community organizer" is going to be the new "San Francisco values." Mitt Romney must look at Rudy with angry, unbridled envy. 

DRILL BABY DRILL! We are inside Terry Southern's head right now. Mitt Romney is wondering why they aren't chanting about tyrannosaurs.

"He immersed himself in Chicago machine politics." Hey, that's us! Sorry, kind of zoned out there.

"Who won? Bin Laden? Al Qaeda?" Isn't that kind of an awkward question? You know, given things?

Rudy is blasting "them" for saying that Sarah Palin running for VP makes her a bad mother. (He really loves being snide--he feels the same way about being a douchebag as I feel about baby animals.) Followed by a cutaway to Bristol Palin. They're cutting away to Bristol Palin every 30 seconds, so I guess the gates have been opened. I think I'm going to be ill.

Hey, it's the woman of the hour. Damn, she's pretty good. I think the accent alone might be worth half a point. Mitt Romney must be grinding his teeth into powder.

The stiff upper lip about Wasilla... she's good. Even if you don't like her, you should be aware of this. Thus far it's really a star-making performance. I wouldn't mention the Bridge to Nowhere, though. I mean, it's not simply a lie... there are T-shirts. You have to finesse that shit.

The thinly veiled torture lust just makes my blood run cold. Coming from someone seemingly normal--someone who hasn't clearly gone 'round the bend like Giuliani or Romney--just makes it all the more terrifying.

ptb: "sarah palin is kind of dressed like hermann goering. DOWNTOWN PRINT IT"

Hang on... now they're doing some kind of halftime show/performance art/country concert... now John Rich is singing a country-rock song... "he got shot down in some Vietnam town... put him in the Hanoi Hilton, thought they could break him in two...." John Rich sings of arms and a man! It's like "Bad Bad Leroy Brown" with creepy overtones about habeas corpus. I'm developing irony cancer.

Sarah Palin's a star; she made herself with that speech, just as Obama did back in 2004. The structure was brilliant, moving from hockey mom to barnburning conservative; it was polished in the cultural details, like the phrase "a servant's heart"; and her glaring weaknesses were returned as culture-war ammunition. She has a presence that's a mass-charismatic version of normal, perhaps closer to Bill Clinton than George W. Bush--composed, unforced, folksy, and radiant, yet with a killer instinct. I'm not surprised the National Review is in a glee meltdown and talking of flipping the ticket.

Will this change the shape of the immediate election? My friend Ben seems to think the speech was too small: "perfectly pitched to a party interested in nothing more than nurturing its own resentments."  Perhaps, but she's better at it than any other prominent Republican since Bush was still trying.

Either way, she's gone from albatross to future star with one speech, which, as a politics, writing, and oratory junkie, I can't help but be impressed with. If you don't understand why some of us wade through the John Warner and Mitt Romney speeches, that's why.


Images:


 
Comments
(please read our policy)
Dean
September 4th - 9:02 a.m.
"'Community organizer' is going to be the new 'San Francisco values.'" Yeah, and the Peace Corps, too. I mean, what kind of losers join the Peace Corps? Why can't they get a real job? I've had enough of that JFK idealism crap. You want to help the poor? Buy a copy of Streetwise. That does real good. Plus it's easy. It's the future.
Marty Hackl
September 4th - 9:27 a.m.
Did we listen to the same speech?! That was one of the most amateurish "major" political speech's I've seen.

Do you set the bar so low?

That speech was degrading to all women if that is the standard.

And it was a night filled with hate and condesention!

Does your criteria for a great speech exclude content? If so then...Hitler, now there was a great speaker!

Agreed, speech making is an art form. Do you judge all art from its skill of execution, but separate from its content?

And in Palin's case, the speech written for her was not composed. It was simply a battery of sound bites.

You must have stayed up too late.
Ben
September 4th - 11:02 a.m.
I think the speech was pretty good, but it was for the base and only the base. I don't see it moving undecideds. What I was afraid of was a Palin who would reach out to Democrats and independents, and she did anything but that.
Olly McPherson
September 4th - 12:05 p.m.
I'm a Democrat, so I'm obviously not in Palin's target audience, but I thought the speech was pretty weak as well. Lots of jabs at Obama and Democrats, using the same tired insults that date back to Reagan, and little uplift about what a McCain-Palin administration would mean for American citizens. Sure, if you're primed to love her, the speech was great--she's speaking your language. But I'm not sure if it was inspiring to undecided voters.
cza
September 4th - 2:45 p.m.
I think Ben's analysis is dead on. It was a series of disconnected small talking points and zingers (some of which were brilliant) and not much more. She pulled back from the few points where she seemed to signal a move to the substantive. I'm shocked at the attempts to put her introductory speech in the same ballpark as Reagan. Have these people heard/read "A Time For Choosing?"
http://www.reaganlibrary.com/reagan/speeches/rende...

I'm no fan of Reagan, but that speech puts Palin's in proper perspective. Her speech was an advanced pep rally.




Chicagoland Blogroll
Area
Art or Idiocy?
Avenue Chicago
Bad at Sports
Balls & My Word
Martha Bayne
Lee Bey
Lynn Becker
Becker-Posner
Beachwood Reporter
Bookslut
Built Chicago
BusinessPOV
Cahiers du Moment
Catalyst
Change of Subject
Chicago's Best Blogs
Chicago Bloggers
Chicago Bubble Blog
Chicago Carless
Chicagoist
Chicago Justice Project
Chicago Reporter
Chicago Reporter (blog)
A Chicago Sojourn
Chicago Syndicate
Chicago Vowel Movers
Christopher Hayes
City of Destiny
Banana Nutriment
Coudal Partners
Daily Daley
Elizabeth Crane
Eunomia
Fake Shore Drive
Daniel Drezner
Deceptively Simple
Design Dissent
DESIGNwatcher
Derivative Works
dirtynerdluv
District 299
Division Street
Driving Sideways
The Dude Abides
Dump Site
Dwsn
Exitcreative
Feast of Fools
52 Teeth
Fish nor Fowl
Forgotten Chicago
Foresight Design Initiative
Free Darko
Found Clothing
The G Spot
Gapers Block
General Carlessness
Golden Rule Jones
GCAW
Hack
Marty Hackl
Harriet
Harold, Daily
Hitsville
Hyde Park Progress
Hyde Park Urbanist
Hypertext
I Hate My Developer
Invisible Magnet
Jazz Age Chicago
Likely Stories
Literago
Logan Square Walks
Love Me/Date Me
Martin Marty Center
Roland Martin
MBIMOTMOG
The Methods Reporter
me[three]dia
My 99 Problems
The New Modernist
Midwestern Microhistory
Mr. Overbrooke
My Bitter Agenda
Ninetyninetyfour
Open Books Radio
Out and About
The Outfit
Outside the Loop
PaperGirl
The Private Intellectual
Radar
Really Boring
Romenesko
Rubber Nun
Lee Sandlin
Second City Cop
THE2NDHAND
The Seeker
The Skyline
Signal vs. Noise
Stick Figures, True Stories
Sustainable Chicago
Thank You Isiah
Time Tells
Thirteen Ways
Tinyluckygenius
Tonic Blotter
Uchiblogo
U of C Law Blog
UptownUpdate
Urban Oasis
The View from Here
Vocalo
The Watcher
What's Your Answer?
West North
Wish You Were Here
Where
Zulkey

©1996-2009 Creative Loafing Media All Rights Reserved.   We welcome your comments and suggestions.