Reader Info
Advertising, subscriptions, staff, privacy policy, contact info, freelancers' guidelines, etc.




News Bites
Michael Miner on the media | RSS | Archive | Search

by Michael Miner on May 21st 2008 - 2:46 p.m.

submit to the windy citizen | del.icio.us | E-mail E-mail this | facebook Facebook

The New York Times published a story this month about Three Oaks, Michigan, a weekend getaway spot about two hours east of Chicago. The story was a little bit off. "There's not a storefront available, and not a chain store in sight," wrote Meghan McEwen, a freelancer based in Detroit. She went on about the art festivals and gallery walks, the Vickers art-house cinema, Drier's Meat Market, "which the poet Carl Sandburg once patronized."

"I don't know many other small, getaway towns that are this progressive," Aron Packer, a Chicago gallerist who'd opened a place in Three Oaks, told McEwen. "I haven't had to change my focus here," he said. "It's just as contemporary, just as challenging as my Chicago gallery." And then there was the Acorn Theater, offering plays, concerts, and comedy in a renovated corset-bone factory. The Acorn's a story in itself -- the Times published that one last December.

But charm hasn't completely insulated Three Oaks from the national economy, which is bad enough, or the Michigan economy, which is even worse, and in fact a few of the storefronts are available. Like the one where Packer's gallery used to be. Last year wasn't good for him in Three Oaks, and when he saw in April what was happening to the price of gasoline, he decided this year would be worse. So he didn't open. And when he spotted the New York Times article on May 9 he shot an e-mail to friends and clients. "Sad but true to say that we have closed our Three Oaks Gallery Space," he said. "Oh the irony! Anyway, Three Oaks is wonderful as you know. . . . Come visit us in Chicago at your leisure."

It's not that McEwen got her facts wrong -- the Times didn't publish them while they were right. She turned in the story last spring expecting the Times to run it last summer in its Friday Escapes section. But a story about a different Michigan haven got into print first, which meant McEwen's had to wait. And rust, as they say, never sleeps.

I remember once diving into a piece in the New Yorker on a Chicago-based institution I knew something about and finding it bewilderingly askew in one niggling detail after another. Later I was told that the New Yorker had had the story in hand something like two years.

UPDATE: On May 23 the New York Times published (and posted online) the following correction: "The Havens column on May 9, about Three Oaks, Mich., described the area’s downtown business district incorrectly. There are a handful of empty storefronts; they are not all taken. The column also referred incorrectly to the Packer Schopf art gallery branch there. That branch has closed." 

I hope Meghan McEwen has broad shoulders -- all the fault being put on her. Aron Packer promptly emailed the Times and asked for a correction of the correction. He felt the paper hadn't made it clear that his main gallery, in Chicago, remains open. His email said, "Already someone has called me to ask if I have closed today. In the gallery world.... Word of closing can be DETRIMENTAL to someone's business."

 

 


Comments
(please read our policy)
carol felsenthal
May 21st - 5:44 p.m.
I have found over the years that when I'm reading the New York Times about a subject I know well, I almost always find mistakes-more than I would find on a subject I'm conversant with in the Chgo Tribune or Chgo Sun-Times.
Michael Sweeney
May 25th - 3:46 p.m.
Another thing about local accuracy can be how long the actual boots on the ground have been on said ground. I will always recall the non-native-Chicagoan-written city guidebook that devoted a story to the singular summer game -- similiar to softball -- that we play here...A game that the author told his readers was called..."Clincher."

I can just picture the semi-befuddled scribe, out at a local Park District diamond, asking a player about the unfamiliar 16-inch softball: "What's that?" (asked while, no doubt, pointing at the orb)...while the player looks on in puzzlement, and answers with the ball's name brand: "Eh? That's a Clincher..."



The News Bites blogroll
Harold, Daily by Harold Henderson

The View From Here by Andrew Patner





Branzburg v. Hayes, the split U.S. Supreme Court decision (1972) generally construed by journalists and judges alike as affirming some sort of reporter's privilege in federal courts.

U.S. Appellate Judge Richard Posner's influential opinion in McKevitt v. Pallasch (2003) telling those journalists and judges they were wrong -- there is no such privilege.

John Milton's Areopagitica (1643), one of the earliest and most eloquent arguments for a free press. Said Milton: "As good almost kill a man as kill a good book; who kills a man kills a reasonable creature, God's image; but he who destroys a good book, kills reason itself, kills the image of God, as it were in the eye."

©1996-2009 Creative Loafing Media All Rights Reserved.   We welcome your comments and suggestions.