Reader Info
Advertising, subscriptions, staff, privacy policy, contact info, freelancers' guidelines, etc.




News Bites
Michael Miner on the media | RSS | Archive | Search


The Tribune put Rick Popely's story on page one last Friday morning, then called him in and fired him later in the day. Which means, he reflects at tellzell.com, "I'll have another memorable story about life at the Tribune." Tell Zell is an LA-based site that invites posters to tell the Tribune Company boss "what you really think." Look for the petition telling Zell that since he's laying them off by the hundreds, his employees (Zells likes to call them his "partners") deserve a representative on the board of directors (with another to represent the LA community).  The goal is 1,000 names and the petition's a long way from getting them.

In a slightly different category from Popely's last story are what a Tribune friend calls "voices from beyond the grave," stories by people no longer there. Look for the telltale signs. For instance, the byline to this dance article in the Sunday paper, "By Sid Smith, Special to the Chicago Tribune." If you're "special to . . ." you're freelancing. Smith took a buyout. And this big story by Mary Ann Fergus in Tuesday's Metro section ends without the usual e-mail address so you can contact the reporter. Fergus was laid off Friday.

Another way to know they're gone: The Tribune phone system asks callers to say the name of the person they want to be connected to. That system no longer recognizes the name of anyone who just left the paper.

I got an anonymous call Monday from someone who wanted me to know the Tribune layoffs disproportionately victimized minority journalists. The caller had no numbers to back up that knock on the Tribune, but here it is again, made publicly in a column by Richard Prince on the Maynard Institute Web site. "It's sad because if you look at the list, it's heavily minority. It looks bad," reporter Ray Quintanilla told Prince. 

Prince alludes to an encounter in the newsroom the day before Quintanilla was fired but doesn't name the columnist Quintanilla says he encountered -- John Kass. Quintanilla heard that Kass had just hired another white legman so he e-mailed him to let him know there were minority reporters at the Tribune who could do the job too. Next thing he knew, Quintanilla tells me, "Kass is standing right on top of me. I can see all of the wrinkles in his shirt, kind of a tan shirt, he was that close to me. His shirt was practically touching me. He said, 'You're calling me a racist' -- something to that effect, I said, 'No, I'm not.' I said I admire his work. And he was screaming again, I had to hang up the phone and at that point I had to stand up. He was physically intimidating." Quintanilla says Kass challenged him to step outside. Kass hasn't gotten back to me with his side of the story.

Quintanilla says he couldn't sleep that night. The next day he was fired and he couldn't sleep that night either.


Comments
(please read our policy)
Sun-Times Subscriber
August 20th - 10:53 a.m.
Speaking of voices from beyond the grave, I see where the Sun-Times is now re-running ancient Royko columns where actual news or current commentary might be published. That's one way to fill the paper with a smaller staff!
NoOneKnows
August 20th - 12:55 p.m.
Notice tellzell.com isn't working? Has it been stifled by Trib higher ups?
Adler
August 20th - 2:35 p.m.
I hope Miner stays on Kass about this. He's such a talentless ass, and he deserves to be called out about this episode with Quintanilla.
Average Joe
August 20th - 2:46 p.m.
It seems that Mr. Quintanilla does not understand that you can't go around shooting off your mouth in the workplace.

Join the rest of the world, Mr. Quintanilla. We can't suggest that co-workers are racist, either. Especially when your evidence to back up your charge is non-existent.
Swanksalot
August 20th - 3:32 p.m.
The Tell Zell link is peculiar:
http://www.tellzell.com/
can't leave off the WWW part.
Inspector Legasse
August 20th - 3:59 p.m.
Kass a racist? Hard to belive that a white South Sider who's always harping on the numerous virtues of the various ethnic groups from which he's descended could be a racist. Kass probaly just dislikes everyone who isn't a Greek / Sicilian from da old neighborhood, which is to say pretty much everyone.
Gerrick Johnson
August 20th - 10:12 p.m.
Kass hired Jason Meisner to replace Tom Rybarczyk.

In terms of the other people laid off, here's what they did to serve Tribune readers:

--Marcia Borucki, asst. subject editor, Home & Garden
--Chris Brown, multimedia producer
--Susan Chan, admin asst, foreign/national news
--Charles Dickinson, asst. subject editor on the metro copy desk
--Bill Fletcher, asst. subject editor, news editing
--Peter Fuller, senior makeup editor for features
--Jason Goodrich, asst. subject editor, news editing
--Lana Gwinn, asst. subject editor, arts and graphics
--Terry Harris, photographer
--Mark Hinojosa, associae managing editor, multimedia
--Julie Hudson, senior editing assistant, news editing
--Paul Iwanaga, picture editor for Q and On the Town
--Cheryl McAllister, public editor's office administrative assistant
--Elaine Melko, asst. subject editor, arts and graphics
--Steven Morris, copy editor, financial news
--Gail Mitchell, graphic artist
--Luke Mundo, editing assistant, Tinley Park bureau
--Emeri O'Brien, asst. subject editor, metro copy desk
--Dwayne Pallanti, engineer, editorial multimedia
--Donna Pierce, features test kitchen
--Stephen Ravenscraft, asst. subject editor, arts/graphics
--Bob Reinalda, asst. subject editor, news editing
--Doug Scott, copy editor, national/foreign news
--Anna Seeto, editing senior assistant, Chicago Tribune magazine
--Gentry Sleets, graphics coordinator
--Nancy Stuermer, asst. subject editor, metro copy desk
--Walter Tokarz, asst. copy editor, sports
--Alberto Trevino, RedEye designer/photographer
--Jeff Williams, Deputy Bureau Chief, Oak Brook Bureau
--Linda Young, Overnight Asst. Subject Editor, Metro
--Stan Ziemba, Overnight Asst. Subject Editor, Metro

The rest (Popely, Haramis, Manor, Jenkins, Freedman, Kampert, Meitrodt, Martinez, Quintanilla) all were people who had regular bylines that would be known to readers.
Fact finder
August 20th - 10:21 p.m.
Melko was a part-time employee who is 9 months pregnant with a broken leg and sprained ankle.
Average Guy
August 21st - 12:42 p.m.
Did Average Joe read the piece? Ray wasn't shooting his mouth off -- he was suggesting that Kass might hire other assistance. Was that hostile? Kass certainly took it that way, but there's nothing here to say that Ray said it in a hostile manner. Maybe Kass is just thin skinned. Nor does the piece suggest that Kass can get people he's mad at fired; Average Joe is stuffing too much into these facts.
John Olsen
August 22nd - 12:25 a.m.
I wish that Zell would have seen the potential for a reality show, on which the remaining Tribune readers would vote off Tribune employees. There are several columnists who I think would serve the paper well by disappearing.
Jimmy Olsen
August 23rd - 3:11 p.m.

Zell missed the ball twice, then -- Kass might have opened up a lawsuit.
Mary Kate Olson
August 25th - 4:12 p.m.
"Quintanilla heard that Kass had just hired another white legman so he e-mailed him to let him know there were minority reporters at the Tribune who could do the job too."

Why should Ray Quintanilla have had a say in who John Kass hires to assist him?

That's just ridiculous. If he was as deficient in news judgment as he was lacking in common sense (and tact), no wonder he was shown the door.

Ashley Olson
August 25th - 4:14 p.m.
On second thought, it seems like Quintanilla's "dying words" were emblematic of his mission as a journalist -- to push minority interests over all else.

Well, then, happy landings to him.
Mark Jeffries
August 26th - 10:35 a.m.
Must be nice to be a racist, Olson.

Chris B.
August 26th - 5:30 p.m.
I think we're all missing the forest for the trees here...

During times where reporters are losing their jobs, why in the hell is Kass still afforded a legman in the first place? What is this, 1974?

Is he too high and mighty to actually do any reporting and research himself? And does his warmed-over right-wing talking points and faux guy-from-the-neighborhood schtick *really* need an assistant to get done? I mean, can't he just hit "F4" on his keyboard to make a Daley-Duffs reference at this point?

I can name a dozen bloggers who produce more interesting, and more volumnious copy on a daily basis, all by themselves. Quintanilla had a valid point, but he missed the larger one.



The News Bites blogroll
Harold, Daily by Harold Henderson

The View From Here by Andrew Patner




Branzburg v. Hayes, the split U.S. Supreme Court decision (1972) generally construed by journalists and judges alike as affirming some sort of reporter's privilege in federal courts.

U.S. Appellate Judge Richard Posner's influential opinion in McKevitt v. Pallasch (2003) telling those journalists and judges they were wrong -- there is no such privilege.

John Milton's Areopagitica (1643), one of the earliest and most eloquent arguments for a free press. Said Milton: "As good almost kill a man as kill a good book; who kills a man kills a reasonable creature, God's image; but he who destroys a good book, kills reason itself, kills the image of God, as it were in the eye."

©1996-2008 Creative Loafing Media All Rights Reserved.   We welcome your comments and suggestions.