Reader Info
Advertising, subscriptions, staff, privacy policy, contact info, freelancers' guidelines, etc.




News Bites
Michael Miner on the media | RSS | Archive | Search


The Tribune -- even the new "if we all think outside the- box maybe this-sorry ship-won't sink" Tribune -- doesn't like to offend. So when stand-up comic Ken Swanborn died the other day, the paper turned up its nose at the paid death notice his family submitted.

The Tribune refused to publish the notice's final line, a nod to Swanborn's sense of humor and political convictions: "In lieu of flowers, please vote Democratic."

Says a woman on the paper's paid-death-notice desk, "If it's considered discriminatory or offensive, they take the line out."

Offensive?

"What if I'm a Republican and I'm offended?"

But instead you offended the family.

"Well, it was not intentional, but we do have protocols and we do have rules we have to follow."

But the family was paying to say this!

"We have guidelines."

The Sun-Times published the death notice as the family wrote it. And Sun-Times columnist Richard Roeper quoted the last line in his tribute to Swanborn, a buddy from the days when they were growing up in Dolton.

Says Carol O'Neill, another Dolton buddy, "Only Swanny could have his obit rejected. He’s been a huge political activist for years. His parents started the movement years ago. When black families started moving into Dolton in the early 60s they were involved in meeting with the Reverend Doctor Martin Luther King. So at an early age Swanny was involved in standing up for social justice. In his mind you were a Democrat or get out of here."

Tribune innovation czar Lee Abrams might want to innovate some common sense.

(H/t Eileen Favorite.)


Comments
(please read our policy)
Right On
September 9th - 8:50 p.m.
How can you refuse a harmless line like that in a death notice?? "Life-long Packer Fan"; politically incorrect for a Chicago paper, and offensive to all CHICAGO BEAR FANS, but that offense they will allow. Who gets to "edit" those adds? Shame on you!! Glad to see that "Swannee, how I love ya, how I love ya" gets the last laugh!!
JoeBu
September 9th - 9:44 p.m.
If the "other" viewpoint was expressed in a similar context was expressed, would it be "censored"? Sad to say, but I think not. Trib is a Republican rag, has been since I've been born. Plus, no one throws a righteously indignant hissy fit like a politically-informed right-winger. Can't turn off the core audience...
Aly
September 9th - 10:31 p.m.
I'm "offended" that the Tribune was worried about what was said in the Guest Book, but didn't care that they offended the family by depriving them of their last wishes. You know that's the last thing that a loved one can do for the one they've lost ( and themselves ) and the Chicago Tribune took that away from the family. Like someone said shame on the Chicago Tribune.
Mike Mosher
September 10th - 9:29 a.m.
Everybody, please forward this story to all Democratic activists and sympathetic journalists around the country. This has to make a stir.

If it wasn't so offensive to the bereaved, it would be purely funny. Perhaps the kind of thing Ken might have used in his comedy act...?

Charles Chi Halevi
September 10th - 9:34 a.m.
Ah, but this works for the best because the huge publicity changed this from a death notice to a major news story.
Former Trib employee (thank goodness)
September 10th - 10:35 a.m.
According to Sam Zell, advertising from "Gentleman's" clubs in acceptable, but according to the classified ad taker (who might not even be in this country, Trib outsourced those jobs a few months ago), "please vote Democratic" is not. Time to move to a country where democracy is actually still practiced.
JSG
September 10th - 10:53 a.m.
The Tribune is a far-far-far right paper. They are essentially a print version of Fox News. I've been boycotting the Tribune for about ten years.

In light of that, this is hardly surprising. Right wingers don't have any sense of decency. The only thing I can say is, the family should have run the ad in the Sun-Times instead.
Michael Miner
September 10th - 11:03 a.m.
The Sun-Times did carry the ad too, as written. The Tribune isn't a far-far-far right paper. But it's a weary, conservative paper with a bureaucratic culture not easily shucked.
Robert Pruter
September 10th - 11:12 a.m.
The bureaucratic answers you got, "we have guidelines," are so utterly mindless that the Chicago Tribune should feel embarrassed. There is nothing offensive about including an inoffensive political message to vote Democratic. Had the message gone into name calling or something, the bureaucrat might have had a case. Truly pathetic.
Gene Skala
September 10th - 11:23 a.m.
Everyone knows the Chicago Tribune is a GOP/Republican paper. That's why no one's reading it anymore. Chicago's four sane choices are The New York Times, The Sun-Times, The Reader and The Onion (of course!).
CHAN WOODS
September 10th - 1:40 p.m.
Regardless of what we are republican or democrate we should honor the family request. What is this world coming to where are our morales? and repect to others this is really sad
DisgruntledExGOP
September 10th - 3:56 p.m.
My beloved Republican grandparents used to say "You pays your money, you takes your choice." The Trib was WRONG not to follow the family's wish, especially since they paid for the notice.
Tribber
September 10th - 4:27 p.m.
Anyone who thinks the Tribune editorial (and by editorial I mean the ones putting words in the paper) was behind nixxing the notice, is off their mark. This is something to take up with the advertising department, NOT the writers/reporters.
Martin Perdoux
September 10th - 6:56 p.m.
Tribber, no one said this was a conspiracy from the Tribune editorial, but merely that one employee, (mis)guided by the culture and political leanings of his/her employer (and maybe his/her own), made a serious and potentially actionable error. If you spent the time researching the name of the person who made the bad call and asked Tribune higher-ups if they stand behind her decision, I doubt they would support it. No paper in their right mind would support this kind of legal exposure.
Janet Swanborn
September 10th - 7:07 p.m.
I am Ken's widow. The ribune has relented and apologized, and will reprint the notice next Sunday with the line in. It will, of course, omit the info about the now-past funeral services.
Carol Decker Swannee's sis
September 12th - 9:45 a.m.
Thanks to all who fought the good fight and continue to fight for peace. My family thanks all of you, his old friends and new friends. You continue to overwhelm us and we so appreciate it. Now let's do, vote democratic and get Obama in. Thanks to all again. Peace, Carol
DM
September 26th - 11:24 a.m.
The Fairness Doctrine would dictate that for every one of these, there needs to be one that reads "Please vote Republican!"
Voting Dead
September 29th - 3:14 p.m.
As a volunteer for various local Democrat campaigns, I can assure you that dead people have been voting for years, sometimes more than once in the same election. This is nothing new.

I am sick thinking of the volunteers walking back into campaign headquarters, announcing not only that they voted, but the number of times they've voted that day.



The News Bites blogroll
Harold, Daily by Harold Henderson

The View From Here by Andrew Patner




Branzburg v. Hayes, the split U.S. Supreme Court decision (1972) generally construed by journalists and judges alike as affirming some sort of reporter's privilege in federal courts.

U.S. Appellate Judge Richard Posner's influential opinion in McKevitt v. Pallasch (2003) telling those journalists and judges they were wrong -- there is no such privilege.

John Milton's Areopagitica (1643), one of the earliest and most eloquent arguments for a free press. Said Milton: "As good almost kill a man as kill a good book; who kills a man kills a reasonable creature, God's image; but he who destroys a good book, kills reason itself, kills the image of God, as it were in the eye."

©1996-2008 Creative Loafing Media All Rights Reserved.   We welcome your comments and suggestions.