Reader Info
Advertising, subscriptions, staff, privacy policy, contact info, freelancers' guidelines, etc.




Clout City
The Reader's Chicago politics blog | RSS | Archive | Search


"Anyone who pays a dime of city taxes should be dismayed by the conduct of these city employees," city inspector general David Hoffman said at a press conference at the federal courthouse Thursday afternoon. He spoke just after “Pat”—as he called U.S. attorney Patrick Fitzgerald—announced bribery charges [see links on right] against 15 people, including seven city employees, stemming from an investigation that started in Hoffman’s office more than a year ago.

“These employees of the buildings department and the zoning department are paid good salaries with excellent benefits,” Hoffman said. “Their jobs were to make sure that the building codes and the zoning ordinances were laws that protect city residents. But what they actually did with their jobs was to make sure the laws were violated. Everything was the exact opposite of the way it should be. The people who we the taxpayers were paying to protect us were actually using their jobs to make sure regular taxpayers got hurt and corrupt real estate developers benefited.”

To anyone who’s ever walked into a building in the city of Chicago, that’s serious stuff, and it should be encouraging to everyone sick of being shaken down for more taxes that at least a few sources of the waste may get it. Even better, Fitzgerald as much as said that there could be more charges on the way.

“There is a problem here bigger than the complaints issued today,” he said, and the investigations into it are not done. “If you were one of those people taking bribes the last few years, you ought to be uncomfortable right now.”

But reformers may not want to get too giddy over the new day coming.

When you read the complaints closely, it’s pretty clear that the feds are going after low-hanging fruit here. It’s rotten fruit, sure. But if there’s a culture of corruption in place—and Fitzgerald and Hoffman certainly sounded like they were describing one Thursday afternoon—I for one don’t see its roots being pulled up by these charges.

According to the feds’ primary source, an “expediter” and “bagman”—i.e., payoff guy—referred to in federal documents as CW1, developers and contractors regularly bribe employees in the city’s departments of buildings, zoning, and construction and permits to speed up the process of signing off on their plans. “Time is money,” as Fitzgerald explained.

In the complaints, though, this “scheme” sounds like it’s being executed by a bunch of louts in a B movie. Most of the bribes detailed are for $100 or $200, though some inspectors held out for bigger stakes: “CW1 advised that it is a common practice for contractors and developers to bribe city officials by providing tickets to sporting events and that CW1 has in the past attended Chicago Bulls basketball games along with certain City of Chicago inspectors.” In one case, an allegedly corrupt developer almost didn’t get his work pushed along because he wasn't sure he could come up with seats to a Bears game that a buildings department official wanted. He breathed a sigh of relief when the official had a death in the family that prevented her from being able to go, and got to work on rounding up Bulls tickets instead.

The feds said payoffs were made in such sinister locales as a Starbucks, the street outside a bank’s ATM lobby, and the entrance to a Payless Shoes store. It should be noted, though, that one was allegedly made outside of “Oprah’s place”—the Wishbone restaurant in the West Loop—because a city employee, Phyllis Mendenhall, no longer thought it appropriate to receive envelopes at her city office.

“I’m going to be stopping by to bring you something,” developer Beny Garneata allegedly told her in a phone conversation recorded by federal officials.

“You know, we can’t, you know we can’t accept anything now,” Mendenhall said.

“Pardon?”

“We can’t accept anything. You know, the, we got new rules.”

“Yah, I heard.”

“Okay, all right well. What time you’ll be by?”

And so go the “new rules.”

Which raises for me the real question out of all this: Who was supervising these people? Who, due to incompetence or something more malign, let this potentially dangerous and totally lame third-rate corruption go on? If there continues to be a culture of selling city services to even the lowest bidder, then who’s created it—who’s tolerated it? If the mayor really is the boss—if he can bully aldermen into making asses of themselves, parks officials into slicing off chunks of public land for private organizations (and then paying to keep them public after all), and planning commissioners into prioritizing his interests regardless of the public's—then how does this possibly exist without tolerance from the top? Really, I don’t get it—will someone please explain? Is it really that hard to get rid of this nonsense? Or is that just the cost of living in a city that’s not Detroit?

I certainly won’t wait to get an answer from the mayor, and Patrick Fitzgerald and David Hoffman were both too cautious to address it in their press conference today. So I guess I’ll leave it open for voters. If you get it, please let me know.


Comments
(please read our policy)
Frank Coconate
May 22nd - 7:17 p.m.
wow! Lets review what the US Attorney has done: 1)Hired Truck(no one above idiot lackey went to jail)2)Hiring Scandal ( They went as far as idiot lackey who drove John Daley) 3) Operation Family Secrets ( They put 4, 80 year old men in jail-no politician even though all were mentioned)4) Inspector Scandal( 15 street level workers) Does anyone see a pattern ....I do !
Orion
May 22nd - 7:48 p.m.
Hoffman is still trying to justify his lame existence, along with Brennan and Fitzgerald.

Fortunately, we will be able to wait out all of them. Brennan will be gone at end of year. Hoffman will not be renewed in '09 and Obama will replace Fitzgerald after the election.

Then the wine will flow once again. We are patient, we will wait. Give up a few of the dumbasses like the small fry and Coconuts.
Orion
May 22nd - 7:56 p.m.
Poor little naive Mick Dumbke. Thinks that things are gonna change ?

Today was the Feds version of the police picking up a few drug dealers on the corner while the real crime and kingpins operate with impunity.

Send a few chumps to prison, rack up some convictions, express some moral indignation, blah, blah, blah.

Nothing is gonna change. Feds, goo-goos, etc. come and go - the machinery stays in place.

Hope you like Detroit
Frank Coconate
May 22nd - 9:22 p.m.
Oreo,
Your wrong. What Mick, Ben, Kass and all the little Coconuts do is keep the heat on the rich and powerful, enough where they can't rest easy. They may not go to jail, but all the little lackeys do. Sooner or later they will run out of lackeys to throw under the bus or the right one opens his/her mouth. We shall overcome! Hows Sheila , Patrick, Brian McGinnis and the rest of the new Kennedys doing? It's funny how the daleys will get paid back.
Orion
May 22nd - 10:01 p.m.

Do the Right Thing:


REGISTER TO VOTE

VOTE IN EVERY ELECTION

HAVE NO DOUBT, VOTE INCUMBENTS OUT


Before every election, compile a list of the Incumbents seeking reelection, from every branch of government, Executive, Legislative and Judicial, and for every contested office, be it city, county, state or federal.

Bring this list with you when you go to vote.


In Primary Elections:

Vote in the Primary of the political party of your choice, preferably that party which has the most Incumbents seeking their party's nomination to be that party's candidate in the General Election.

The goal is to deny Incumbents reelection in the General election, so, if the Incumbent fails to win their party's Primary Election, that Incumbent will not be that party's candidate in the General Election.

If the Incumbent has only 1 challenger, vote for that challenger.

If the Incumbent has 2 or more challengers, then, to maximize the votes for a single challenger, vote according to ballot name position, following these two, simple rules of thumb:

1. If the Incumbent's name is listed FIRST, vote for the Challenger whose name is listed LAST

or

If the Incumbent's name is NOT listed first, vote for the Challenger whose name IS LISTED FIRST.

Denying the Incumbents their party's nomination to run in the General election will ensure that those Incumbents will now be Ex-Incumbents.


In the General Election, if given the opportunity, vote for any candidate who is NOT a member of the Democratic or Republican party.


Breaking the stranglehold these two party's have on our governments is the only means of returning democracy to Our Democracy, Of the
People, By the People and For the People.

Anything less is, and has been, proven to be futile.


HAVE NO DOUBT, VOTE INCUMBENTS OUT
Donovan
May 23rd - 12:59 a.m.
This hits some alderman too
like Manny Flores (the ward where the CW witness was from) and
Ald Billy Banks who knows some of the indictees.
More to come
INCUMBENTS ALWAYS WIN
May 23rd - 3:04 a.m.
DONT REGISTER TO VOTE

DONT VOTE IN EVERY ELECTION

HAVE NO DOUBT, KEEP VOTE INCUMBENTS IN

LOOK WHOS ELECTED, IM WINNING
open book
May 23rd - 4:57 a.m.
No body wants to bust out the higher ups in this cess-pool.Soon I will reveal the command structure of this criminal Enterprise. You must realize the corruption in the Building dept goes beyond the Building Dept. It extends to the 11th and 19th wards,certain big time Developers,Certain big time law firms, and Constrution companies like Walsh,and Pepper. When Building Commissioner Stan Kaderbek resign,he went to work for Walsh Construction,as a Manager.Walsh was the primary contractor of the 225 million lower wacker drive project. Stan Kaderbek was the City project coordinator,overseeing the project. Then he was appointed Building Commissioner,definitely a conflict of interest.In other words there is cabal of evil interests,that would find a professional trained ,honest inspection process adherring to National standards, would slow up business. Remember the only reason you have a Building department to begin with,is due to the Insurance industry. This goes all the way back to the Chicago fire.
Jolt
May 23rd - 5:09 a.m.
How many of these fools are going to fall on their swords for Daley. Christopher Kozicki resigns, Brian Mcginnis resigns,Richard Rodriguez reassign to run Dept of Aviation. Former Commissioner John Knight:Forced to resign,Former Commissioner Stan Kaderbek ;forced to resign,and many others. Daley is able to buy or threaten former employees to ensure their silence.
Ian
May 23rd - 6:40 a.m.
who cares if it's only low hanging fruit they're going after? Fuck 'em, make the lowest of the low start squealing and who knows what might happen.
Orion
May 23rd - 6:54 a.m.
Fortunately, the low fruit hangers still abide by the dictim of honor among thieves and will not rat out. Plus, they do their bit in the joint, we take care of their families for them while they are incarcerated and when they come out, we find a job for them.
RE:orion
May 23rd - 6:56 a.m.
YES! He also locked him out of his office ,and called the police on Knight. Knight went back to his clout(REV AUTHUR BRAZIER)and threaten to exposed the inter-working of the criminal Enterprise.Daley keep Knight on the payroll as a ghost for 6 months to buy his silence. The irony Knight is Knight is at Moody bible college training to be a preacher.
Zip
May 23rd - 6:59 a.m.
I bet an annal White boy like Kozicki will flip,at the prospect of going to Sandstone Minn. Remember this guy might drop the soap.
Frank Coconate
May 23rd - 7:56 a.m.
If you read the Chicago Sun-Shine today "THE DALEY PAPER" everything is fine in Daleyworld!!!!!The front page is a joke. Fran Spielman and Frank Main should be arrested for impersonating reporters. US Attorney should check their Bank accounts.
Grand Beach
May 23rd - 8:01 a.m.
The residents of Grand Beach Michigan,are generating a petition to requestthe Daley's to leave. The residents have experienced fires, dead bodies,gang beat downs by Pat,and a host of problem since the Daleys have move in. Please Mr Mayor goes else this Holiday,we need some peace and quiet. BUT PLEASE HAVE A NICE MEMORIAL DAY.
RE:COCOMAN
May 23rd - 8:09 a.m.
Fran Spielman's husband has a government consulting contract I have been told.
realism
May 23rd - 9:15 a.m.
If there was strict adherance to National Building codes,little would be built in Chicago. The city Building codes are not written by Engineers, architects,or trades men ,but by lawyers.Strong code enforcement would slow down the process,and cut into profits.
Keeping it Real
May 23rd - 11:03 a.m.
Mario Olivo is a Cuban guy with Banks but he is also close to MANNY FLORES and his clownish drunkin snowman cousin the Ward Sup MANNY GONZALEZ also known as MANNY G. Plumbing inspections?
Part time plumbing jobs by the Ward Sup? Some before he became war sup? Money in the Flores family floating around??
Fixing of jobs and permits?

Pretty boy Manny Flores would definitely be somebody's bitch in jail.
Ex-Employee
May 23rd - 11:25 a.m.
I worked in City Hall for two years (left last year). In my opinion, Zoning and Buildings and DCAP were unbelievably poorly run; spending time in Zoning it never even seemed like there even WAS a supervisor, let alone a competent one. I saw, day after day, some of the worst customer service and some of the most uncaring, un-empathetic public service I can imagine. All three departments - but especially Zoning - routinely spent months on a case, only to make a seemingly arbitrary decision. I don't blame Zoning Administrator Patty Scudiero - though she certainly should have the courage to hold her "employees" accountable - I blame those under her and the system of patronage that allowed them to get hired and that allows them to continue holding the public and the laws hostage.

That said, there are BAD departments and there are GOOD departments - there are thousands of dedicated and clean city employees serving the public everyday. The continued and detrimental corruption of the few bad departments shouldn't taint the perception of other well-run and relatively efficient departments.
City Worker
May 23rd - 1:59 p.m.
Cocoman is walking tall these days! He drives the Daley's crazy!!!!
steve
May 23rd - 2:04 p.m.
I think the real problem here, is that certain city departments are hiring people so unintelligent and inexperienced, that they would risk their jobs for sporting event tickets...I bet some of these resumes are laughable.
Future statement State Rep. John Fritchey
May 23rd - 2:07 p.m.
I know nothing, I see nothing, I hear nothing!!!
Coconut Is A Moron
May 23rd - 3:18 p.m.
He goes to Bijou world, Ho Ho!!!. With his BOYFRIENDS Tony & Marko, Mick Dumbke, Joe Whore, Jesse Jr, et al.
RE: EX-EMPLOYEE
May 23rd - 3:55 p.m.
What qualifications do the higher have. The city Building Department is run by lawyers. Daley appoint people to run things they have no knowledge of. Zoning,Buildings,Dcap are nothling but window dressing created to satisfy,State and insurance requirements,and serve the Mayor Aldermen,and Mob. The building Department stays out of way of Major Development. There are only 10 New Construction inspectors,to check all new developments. If Chicago's Building code adheres to National standards, development would be less profitable.
Orion
May 23rd - 4:17 p.m.
Jolt wrote:
Former Commissioner John Knight:Forced to resign,Former Commissioner

There was a post to explain why he was forced to resign, yet the "moderator" erased it. But lets other libelous statements stay on the board.
RE:orion
May 23rd - 7:58 p.m.
You and I may not agree on much,but I think you are right. It seems like when some criticizes RON THE BUTTERFLY HUBERMAN THEIR POST IS ERASED. HMMMM
Orion
May 24th - 7:59 a.m.
I think Kate has a crush, that can never be requited, on Ron.
Lon
May 24th - 3:31 p.m.
THe Mayor is either in control or he is not. When they indict ten more in the next month, the noose will tighten. on Who? The ones frequenting the zoning department getting favors doled out. WHo are those attorneys?
RE:LON
May 24th - 7:05 p.m.
I agree ! the indicted Building Inspectors are just getting the crumbs from Daley's table. Law firm like Daley & George. Former Building Commissioner who now works as a partner for Mayer& Plat. There are a list of Lawyers whom, have a blank check with Buildings and Zoning. I just named a few.
Jolt
May 24th - 7:08 p.m.
The former Building Commissioner who is a full partner at Mayer& Plat is Mary Richardson.
The Old Building Inspector.....
May 24th - 9:50 p.m.
Is a dipshit.
Bozo T. Clown
May 24th - 9:54 p.m.
As is the one formerly known as "Popeye Arms".....Norma Reyes, Before she became a toothpick.
Where did the post go?
May 25th - 8:30 a.m.
Four guys that had a major part in this scandal had their post removed. A bunch of no-nothing retard post stupid crap with a few names that skipped out in time. I am sorry to say but you reactionaries do not know nothing. All you do is rehash what the real movers and shakers bring to light. I do not know why one wash out is still posting here? He is old news.
Frank Coconate
May 25th - 1:24 p.m.
Lets all remember the Veterans of War. My father Gabe was a World War II Navy Veteran who won a medal for Guatacanal. He taught me how to handle deepwater!

To " Where did the post go?": four guys?
Dave Hoffman, Patrick Fitzgerald,Jay Stewart,Terry Brunner that's the four I know who started the investigation. DesPlaines Boy stay in the suburbs we're you belong.
Code Warrior
May 25th - 4:48 p.m.
FEDERAL AGENT RAID DALEY'S BUILDING DEPARTMENT: At least 30 people will be arrested,for bribery and corrupt business practices.For years Whistle Blowers: PATRICK MCDONOUGH,CHARLES WALKER, VICTOR CROWN, MICHAEL MCGANN have exposed and alerted Federal Agents,and the public,to this vicious Criminal Enterprise,called the "Building Department" Finally their efforts are bearing fruit. Illegal hirings and promotions,along with crooked inspections,and permit approvals are the norm. Its no wonder why the Citizens are at risk,and have died, due to this Criminal Organization. The clout list,with its 5000 names,contain many Building Department employees. Aalong with their clout. Daley's relatives are well represented along with names like Brian Mcginnis,Christopher Kozicki and others,along with 11th and 19th ward residents. One of the most incompetent people helping to cover up corruption is Scott Loeff(Assistant Commissioner:clout: Ald Bernard Stone) Scott was over heard threatening to fire an Inspector ,if he talked to Federal Agents. He eventually did have the Inspector fired,unfotunately the Inspector remained silent. Its no wonder why Chicaoans have witnessed deaths in Lincoln Park(13) E2 Night club(21)69 .w.Washington(6) and Tiara Woods. Another culprit is Deputy Commissioner Attorney Dennis, his job is to try to make illegal acts,legal.There should be an outside audit of the Department and all of its Annual and Permit inspections. Daley ,Bernard Stone, Ray Suarez,Lawyers,Developers, selected Contractors, have long resisted attempts to align Chicago's inspectional practices with National standards.The Feds need to do a R.I.C.O indictment on Daley and officials in the Building Department. Don't just focus on the low hanging fruit. The Building Department should be placed on Federal receivership, or appoint a monitor for 3 years, to protect the public.
Dave Hoffman, Patrick Fitzgerald,Jay Stewart,Terry Brunner
May 25th - 8:17 p.m.
We can share the credit Code Warriors. Just be sure your back yard in DesPlaines is clean. Also when the plumbers case comes up about living outside Chicago, these same Inspectors you set up don't come back to bite you in your ass!
Jerry Hill
May 26th - 8:20 a.m.
This should do well for the IG when he wants a raise next year.
Will they keep uncovering the corrupt schemes in the zoning department that goes all the way to the state house and back, to the county board and back, to the Govs office and back and end at city hall. The money must be great to commit so many illegal acts but the small fish aren't the ones benefitting. The amount of dollars you get from zoning changes is huge, the extra bonus for developers goes back to somebody. Who are the somebodies? not the small fries at the input desk for sure. Who are the developers lawyers?
re:jerry hill
May 26th - 4:15 p.m.
Its bigger than Inspector its involves judges, MARA GEORGE AND HER CORPORATION COUNSEL OFFICE. Mayer & Plat Former Building Comissioner Mary lowry Richardson, Carpenters Union #13,The Building Department is larger than the Zoning Dept. Zoning Broke off from Building Dept decades ago, to promote a power sharing arrangement among theives. Banks controls Zoning ,but he also has a lot of power in the Department of Buildings. Bank's ward organization has many members in both Zoning & Buildings. His Ward Secretary Ralph puluso, was once the Director of Conservation,in the Building Dept before he resigned. The Housing court lawyers and judges are also involved and tainted.
Zip
May 26th - 4:48 p.m.
are the Code Warriors taking applications
Just Do It
May 28th - 6:25 p.m.
REGISTER TO VOTE

VOTE IN EVERY ELECTION

HAVE NO DOUBT, VOTE INCUMBENTS OUT


Before every election, compile a list of the Incumbents seeking reelection, from every branch of government, Executive, Legislative and Judicial, and for every contested office, be it city, county, state or federal.

Bring this list with you when you go to vote.


In Primary Elections:

Vote in the Primary of the political party of your choice, preferably that party which has the most Incumbents seeking their party's nomination to be that party's candidate in the General Election.

The goal is to deny Incumbents reelection in the General election, so, if the Incumbent fails to win their party's Primary Election, that Incumbent will not be that party's candidate in the General Election.

If the Incumbent has only 1 challenger, vote for that challenger.

If the Incumbent has 2 or more challengers, then, to maximize the votes for a single challenger, vote according to ballot name position, following these two, simple rules of thumb:

1. If the Incumbent's name is listed FIRST, vote for the Challenger whose name is listed LAST

or

If the Incumbent's name is NOT listed first, vote for the Challenger whose name IS LISTED FIRST.

Denying the Incumbents their party's nomination to run in the General election will ensure that those Incumbents will now be Ex-Incumbents.


In the General Election, if given the opportunity, vote for any candidate who is NOT a member of the Democratic or Republican party.


Breaking the stranglehold these two party's have on our governments is the only means of returning democracy to Our Democracy, Of the
People, By the People and For the People.

Anything less is, and has been, proven to be futile.


HAVE NO DOUBT, VOTE INCUMBENTS OUT
les
June 13th - 11:31 a.m.
Which raises for me the real question out of all this: Who was supervising these people? Who, due to incompetence or something more malign, let this potentially dangerous and totally lame third-rate corruption go on?


the mayoral appointee is responsible, but he got a buyout and went to the airport job. What's so hard to figure out?



©1996-2009 Creative Loafing Media All Rights Reserved.   We welcome your comments and suggestions.